February 25, 2026

Explore the Best Materials for Deck Construction in New York State: Decking Materials Comparison

This article will explore various decking materials, their benefits, and maintenance tips to help you make informed decisions. We will cover the top wood types, the advantages and disadvantages of composite and wood decking. By understanding these aspects, you can create a deck that is both functional and visually appealing.

Creating a stunning deck requires careful consideration of materials that not only enhance the aesthetic appeal but also ensure durability and longevity. Homeowners often face the challenge of selecting the best materials for deck designs that can withstand the elements while providing a beautiful outdoor space. This article will explore various decking materials, their benefits, and maintenance tips to help you make informed decisions. We will cover the top wood types, the advantages and disadvantages of composite and wood decking. By understanding these aspects, you can create a deck that is both functional and visually appealing.

What Are the Top Deck Wood Types for Durable and Beautiful Decks?

When it comes to decking, wood remains a popular choice due to its natural beauty and versatility. The most common types of wood used for decks include pressure-treated wood, cedar, and ipe. There is a new category of thermally treated Ash and Pine decking products that have an enhanced aesthetic and are typically pre-finished. Each type of wood decking has its unique characteristics, making them suitable for different preferences and budgets.

What Are the Benefits and Drawbacks of Pressure Treated Wood?

Pressure-treated wood is a widely used decking material known for its cost-effectiveness and resistance to decay. This type of wood undergoes a treatment process that infuses preservatives, making it less susceptible to rot and insect damage. However, it can have environmental concerns due to the chemicals used in the treatment process. Homeowners should weigh the benefits of affordability and durability against potential health and environmental impacts.

In our region in New York and the Northeast USA, Pressure Treated lumber is still the main lumber choice for deck framing and a requirement to maintain code compliance in most municipalities.  There are other viable framing options, such as steel and composite framing, but most of these options are still a bit too expensive for average residential homeowners.

Pressure Treated Benefits:

  • Affordable

    Pressure treated lumber is the most affordable decking option available in the Northeast
  • Readily Available

    Pressure treated lumber is easy to find in various lengths, widths, and thicknesses
  • Versatile

    Pressure treated lumber is available in 5/4 thickness and 2x thicknesses.  This provides more structural choices than most manufactured decking products that are mainly 5/4 only.
  • Durability against Pests

    In the Northeast, PT Lumber is effective at handling most pest concerns if installed and maintained properly.
  • Structurally Strong

    PT Lumber is most commonly made of Southern Yellow Pine on the east coast of the US and this species of pine offers a great balance of strength and workability.  This species allows you to comfortably span 16” on joists in most applications, where many composites require smaller spans due to their composition.

Pressure Treated Drawbacks:

  • Health Concerns

    Pressure treated lumber relies on chemicals for it’s protection from the elements.  These chemicals can be a concern for some homeowners depending on their intended use of their deck. 
  • Tendency to Warp/Crack

    Pressure treated lumber is wet from the lumberyard, so it gets installed in a state of saturation where the lumber is full of moisture.  As the boards and lumber begin to dry out, the boards can bend, warp, and crack more aggressively than other types of lumber or composites.  Be sure your installer takes this into consideration when installing to limit board movement.
  • Maintenance Required

    Pressure Treated lumber requires maintenance to protect the wood from UV damage and moisture. This is often done with regular staining to add a layer that provides protection.
  • Delayed Final Result

    Pressure Treated lumber is wet when installed and therefore needs to dry out before being finished with a stain.  This means that you have to factor in the dry time after installation.  This can be frustrating for some homeowners and the project can feel unfinished for some because after construction the deck still requires finishing at a later date.

How Do Cedar and ipe Enhance Natural Deck Beauty and Longevity?

Cedar and ipe are prized for their aesthetic appeal and natural resistance to insects and decay. These woods offer a rich color and grain that can enhance the overall look of any outdoor space. Additionally, both types of wood have a longevity that can surpass pressure-treated options when properly maintained. Their natural oils help protect against moisture and pests, making them a great choice for homeowners looking for both beauty and durability.

Western Red Cedar Benefits:

Disclaimer: Cedar is often used as a catch-all term for all cedar species, but Western Red Cedar is the species you should source for exterior decking projects.

  • Most affordable non-treated option

    Western Red Cedar is more than pressure treated lumber usually by a factor of up to 2x, but is still less expensive than composite materials.
  • Natural Product

    Western Red Cedar is an all natural material. It still contains chemicals, but they are natural occurring chemicals in the wood that offer protection from pests and elements.
  • Most eco-friendly option

    Western Red Cedar is a renewable natural resource that is grown in the United States and Canada.  It has a natural life-cycle and does not produce any artificial by-products.  Many will argue that composites are eco-friendly, which is mostly just marketing language.  In reality, composites are made up of plastics, which offer durability, but certainly not the most eco-friendly option.
  • Available Most of the Time

    Western Red Cedar availability can vary slightly in the Northeast, but in general you can find cedar products and they are offered in various options for outdoor deck systems.
  • Durability against Pests

    The natural chemicals and oils in Western Red Cedar offer great natural protection from pests.
  • Lightweight

    Western Red Cedar is significantly lighter than composites and pressure treated decking options.  This can be beneficial for some applications and diy builders.  There is some reduction in strength compared to Southern Yellow Pine, so be sure factor this in if using it for structural components.

Western Red Cedar Drawbacks:

  • Health Concerns

    Cedar wood dust can be irritating to some, so installers should still perform safe wood cutting practices.
  • Potential UV Damage

    Cedar decking can be weathered quickly by the sun.  Exposed deck locations should use a product to protect the wood from excessive uv exposure, which can break down a deck over time.
  • Maintenance

    Cedar decking requires maintenance in the form of staining or oiling to protect the wood from exposure to UV rays and excessive moisture.

Odd Job Adam specializes in expert guidance and hands-on carpentry for deck building and repair using various materials, including these top wood types. Their personalized service and local expertise ensure that your deck is built to last.

Why Choose Composite Decking: Benefits and Maintenance Compared to Wood?

Composite decking has gained popularity as a modern alternative to traditional wood. Made from a blend of wood fibers and plastic, composite materials offer several advantages, including low maintenance and high durability. Unlike wood, composite decking does not require regular staining or sealing, making it a convenient choice for busy homeowners.

What Makes Composite Decking a Modern Alternative for Homeowners?

Composite decking is designed to mimic the look of natural wood while providing enhanced durability. It is resistant to fading, staining, and scratching, making it ideal for high-traffic areas. 

How Does Composite Decking Reduce Maintenance Effort and Costs?

One of the significant benefits of composite decking is its low maintenance requirements. Homeowners can save time and money by avoiding the need for regular staining, sealing, and repairs associated with traditional wood decks. A simple wash with soap and water (always check manufacturer recommendations for your decking material) is often all that is needed to keep composite decking looking new. This ease of maintenance allows homeowners to enjoy their outdoor spaces without the hassle of constant upkeep.

To ensure you choose the right composite decking for your needs, consider consulting with professionals like Odd Job Adam, who can provide expert guidance on the best options available.

Guide Author
Adam Emmerich

help@oddjobadam.com

Subscribe to our newsletter
Subscribe
By subscribing you agree to with our Privacy Policy
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.